The "Patriarchy Hannah" Drama Explained And The Reformed Porn Star To Trad Larp

Meet Patriarchy Hannah, a.k.a. The woman behind a “tradwife” account on X that turned out to be an alleged criminal…and a pornstar?

If you’ve been blissfully unaware, here’s the quick version: X users uncovered the truth about Patriarchy Hannah, and she isn’t real – at least not in the way she claimed to be.

Who Is Patriarchy Hannah, Really?

The X (formerly Twitter) account @harmonizedgrace presented itself as a devoted Christian wife with 14 children. Maybe that should have been a clue to the deception. 14 kids, and you’re on the app all day tweeting? She tweeted about the typical talking points on X: traditional gender roles, anti-feminism, bread-baking, homesteading, loving her husband, etc. Her husband, Tony, supposedly owned a construction company and an entire town – “Tony Town,” as she called it – where they and their many children lived.  

She frequently showered young women with encouragement, which made her seem like a wholesome, big-sister type figure. But mixed in with that sugary demeanor were bizarre, often hypocritical takes. She once called conservative commentator Allie Beth Stuckey a "feminist," shamed postpartum women by insisting they didn’t "deserve" a rest period, and claimed to cook everything from scratch for her husband—while also constantly talking about eating junk food.

Hannah had a now-deleted podcast titled "Patriarchy Country," in which she platformed commentator Richard B. Spencer. Spencer is known for his neo-Nazi and antisemitic views.

Then there were the alleged text messages between her and “Tony,” her supposed husband, which she eagerly shared with followers. Apparently, many people had spoken to Hannah via phone calls and Zooms, but she always had a reason for not being on camera.

One of the sleuths to make a post about Hannah, Ryan Duff, believes she’s a “completely fabricated persona.” Patriarchy Hannah is reportedly a 37-year-old woman in Arkansas named Jennifer Bays. Others found that Bays was arrested in 2011 for (you'll never believe this) identity theft.

Another user posted an article on Hannah's alleged brother (Leo Bays) in real life. The headline reads: "Former case worker sent to jail after forcing child to watch pornography." Some are speculating that Leo is actually a man who identifies as a woman, formerly named Elizabeth.

He wrote that in November 2023, Patriarchy Hannah claimed her husband built a house for their son and soon-to-be daughter-in-law. But the internet quickly matched the house to a property built in 2020 by two sisters for their now-deceased mother. Property records seem to confirm it. Even the propane tank and river-facing stairs matched Google Street View images. When people pointed it out, Hannah deleted the post.

Then, there was an Amazon receipt. A woman who had received a stroller from "Hannah" found that the sender was listed as "Jennifer." The Amazon account was registered under Jennifer’s mother, Jo Lynn, with an Arkansas address. @ryancduff explained it best: "The Amazon receipt said 'From Jennifer' and the name on the Amazon account was Jennifer’s mother Jo Lynn with an address in Arkansas. This address matches a whole set of addresses Jennifer and her parents have lived at across Arkansas and Louisiana."

Hannah had also once mentioned the passing of her grandmother, which, surprise, happened to coincide exactly with the death of Jennifer Bays’ grandmother. However, Jennifer’s grandmother’s obituary made no mention of a "Hannah" or her supposed 14 children. In fact, it only listed three great-grandchildren in total.

What about Tony? @ryancduff thinks he doesn't exist. "So far there is no evidence that Tony exists besides some lightly used X account that would occasionally interact with Hannah," he wrote. "Per Jennifer's grandmother's obituary, Jennifer is not married. As for the construction company Tony supposedly owns, building homes, it turns out that’s actually what Jennifer’s father does."

It turns out Patriarchy Hannah had also stolen images of a woman named Allison to maintain her facade. Allison has since come forward and said she knew a woman named Jennifer Bays (the purported woman behind the Patriarchy Hannah account). What's interesting is that Allison remembers Jennifer having a husband named Tony, but he later died from an overdose.

According to user @potlucklauren on X, "Just spoke to Allison & her partner and they asked me to post this. She knew Jennifer from her past who had a husband named Tony who died of an overdose. She was so thankful for us reaching out & confirmed that the voice of ‘Hannah’ belongs to Jennifer. The jig is officially up."

Hannah also claimed to be close friends with a Pastor named Jeff Durbin. When he was asked about her, he said that he did not know who she was. "I do not know who this person is. And I've never stayed at her house and eaten her kids' snacks. My wife chuckled when she saw that claim," he wrote.

"Because I generally don't stay at people's houses. It makes me very, very uncomfortable. I can only recall doing it with a family I am very close to. In Ireland. And their names are not Hannah and Tony. :)"

The Sourdough Jar

By now, the internet had strong suspicions about Jennifer Bays being the real person behind Patriarchy Hannah.  

Hannah posted a picture of her starter, but sleuths zoomed in and caught the reflection of a woman who looked eerily similar to Jennifer Bays’ mugshot from 2011.

Patriarchy Hannah deleted her account soon after, but the digging didn’t stop. More internet sleuths claimed an even more shocking discovery possibly surfaced—that Jennifer was alleged to have a history as an adult content creator under the name "CurvyJForYou," branding herself as a BBW (big beautiful woman) in the online porn industry. That particular claim seems highly unlikely given the voices don’t match, despite the physical resemblance and shared first name.

And if there’s one thing people do know about Patriarchy Hannah, it’s her voice—she was constantly on Twitter Spaces, weighing in on every trad discourse imaginable. But perhaps the biggest giveaway? Despite claiming to be a devoted mother to 14 adopted children, not once did anyone ever hear so much as a peep from a single kid in the background.

What Can We Learn From Patriarchy Hannah?

This all begs the question—why? Why go to such extreme lengths to fabricate an identity instead of cultivating a real one? The irony is that she became the exact opposite of everything she claimed to represent. Instead of being secure and fulfilled, she was isolated. Instead of being disciplined and thriving in her femininity, she was unhealthy. Instead of being tethered to truth, she built an elaborate web of deception. And the internet—far from being a tool for connection—became her greatest means of escape.

The fallout from her deception has been swift and overwhelming. Many who once admired her have expressed sadness, anger, and outright disbelief at the lengths she went to in order to deceive her audience. For those who genuinely believed in her message, this probably feels like a betrayal—not just of trust, but of the ideals she pushed.

The internet is ruthless with frauds, but beyond the memes and mockery, there’s a real sense of disappointment. People wanted to believe in her. They wanted her to be real. And now, all that remains is the reflection of a mugshot in a sourdough starter—a fitting metaphor.

This isn’t just about one person getting caught in a lie, though. It’s a cautionary tale. The impulse to create a fantasy online rather than build something meaningful in real life is more common than we’d like to admit, and it’s a trap that far too many people are falling into.

Why Are There So Many Trad Larpers?

I get the appeal of "trad" life to some degree. The modern dating scene is a nightmare, many jobs are soul-crushing, and feminism somehow managed to promise women they could have it all while ensuring they enjoy none of it. So, it’s no wonder that more young women are looking for an alternative—something more stable and fulfilling.

But these picture-perfect “trad” influencers flooding social media with their hot takes and humble brags aren’t actually living the lives they promote. They’re not busy homemakers, doting wives, or self-sacrificing mothers. In fact, they’re rarely even married, often divorced, childless, and probably a lot more dysfunctional than the women they spend all their time chastising online. 

Grifters and the "Trad" Rebrand Pipeline 

If you’ve noticed that most of the women leading the online trad movement have suspiciously non-traditional pasts, you’re not alone. There’s an undeniable pattern emerging in the online trad space—an odd pipeline where women with the least traditional pasts suddenly become the loudest voices on what it means to be a “real” traditional woman.  

Many of these influencers “used” to focus on their careers and pushed feminist talking points. Some made names for themselves as porn stars. Now, they’re “reformed” and using their new worldview as their motivation to “help” other women. The only problem is that these self-made "experts" on womanhood aren't actually worried about helping others as much as they're interested in making a name for themselves.

These "transformations" are less likely to be sincere personal growth and more likely simple opportunism. This isn’t to say people can’t change—real growth is admirable, and rejecting past mistakes is a good thing. But genuine transformation requires humility and self-control, two qualities that are hard to cultivate when your primary goal is attention. Many of these self-proclaimed reformed feminists haven’t given themselves the time or space to truly embody the values they now preach.

Real Trad Life is Hard

Truly traditional life isn’t just about baking sourdough and opining about femininity all day—it requires knowledge, discipline, and real character. It’s not something you can LARP your way into with aesthetic choices and simple platitudes.

Marriage and motherhood require real work. Choosing the right spouse isn’t as simple as making a viral post about high-value men—it’s about building a beautiful relationship that can endure stress, sacrifice, and the passage of time. Running a household isn’t just candlelit dinners and cute chore charts—it’s exercising wisdom consistently across every area of your life.

None of this is to say a traditional life is bad—in fact, it’s one of the wisest and most fulfilling paths a woman can take. But many of the women selling this lifestyle aren’t actually living it. And the reason they’re not upfront about what it really takes is simple—they don’t have what it takes yet. They haven't fully stepped back from destructive, attention-seeking patterns and learned how to choose a better way to live.

The women who are truly thriving in their traditional roles aren’t spending 40 hours a week arguing online about who's doing it best. The ones raising kids, maintaining strong marriages, creating happy homes, and inspiring others don’t have endless time to post about it.

They’re too busy actually living it.

Subscribe today to get unlimited access to all of Evie’s premium content.